Skip to the main content of this page?
Find other sites and services by the City of Greater Sudbury
Greater Sudbury Airport
greater sudbury airport logo
Greater Sudbury Airport
Your journey begins with us. Avoid the hassles of the highway and travel worry-free with the Greater Sudbury Airport. Check here for arrivals, departures, traveller information and more!
Your Local Library
greater sudbury public library logo
Your Local Library
Greater Sudbury Public Library is proud to offer a wide range of bilingual services and collections which meet the information and leisure needs of all ages.
Heritage Museums
sudbury museums logo
Heritage Museums
Discover our rich past. Explore four local museums through digital imaging, audio and video. The site also features the INCO Triangle Digital Archives.
Invest Sudbury
invest sudbury logo
Invest Sudbury
The Greater Sudbury Development Corporation is the engine for local economic development. Explore initiatives to attract, develop and retain business in our city.
Sudbury Tourism
sudbury tourism logo
Sudbury Tourism
Greater Sudbury is a place for adventure. Choose from world-renowned attractions, urban comforts and outdoor getaways. Packages are available.
Regional Business Centre
regional business centre logo
Regional Business Centre
Let us help you find what you need to succeed. Our not-for-profit organization provides information and resources to fund, launch and grow your business, free of charge.

Greater Sudbury

Description and Overview of Traffic Calming

Traffic calming represents a component of traffic management techniques to reduce the impacts of traffic on neighbourhood communities and other public facilities such as parks, school areas, and community centres.  Traffic calming has been used in North America to:

  • Improve neighbourhood liveability;
  • Increase road user safety;
  • Implement crime prevention programs through access restriction methods such as road closures and one-way streets; and
  • Promote urban redevelopment.

Communities throughout North America have experienced significant growth in traffic due to automobile dependence and urban sprawl.  These trends in automobile travel have placed considerable strains on the road network and the ability to safely (e.g. perceived or real collision potential) accommodate all road users within the public right-of-way.  In many cases, the lack of arterial road capacity has resulted in motorists choosing to use collector and residential roadways to circumvent a congested turning movement, intersection or corridor.

In summary, there are a number of negative traffic impacts in some of the communities that result from inappropriate use of neighbourhood streets by drivers, as listed below.  In general, these typically occur in older established neighbourhoods next to busy traffic areas. However, traffic issues may also occur in newer subdivisions depending on the road network and adjacent activities:

  • Arterial road congestion results in motorists looking for parallel or alternative routes to reach their destinations;
  • These parallel/alternative roads accommodate greater traffic volumes and begin to function as they were never intended.  For example, a local residential or collector roadway becomes a mid-block arterial road;
  • Motorists operate vehicles at speeds which are not appropriate for the residential roadway and/or the roadside environment;
  • The safety of all road users is decreased due to volume, speed and other compliance issues; and/or
  • Enforcement resources are called upon to provide frequent enforcement of numerous problem areas and cannot sustain the level of enforcement to effectively address these traffic related issues.

One response to these problems is the self-enforcing option of traffic calming devices.  Provided below is a summary of the general benefits and disbenefits of traffic calming, followed by an overview of available devices.

Benefits and Disbenefits of Traffic Calming

In the development of the Canadian Guide to Neighbourhood Traffic Calming(Transportation Association of Canada / Canadian Institute of Transportation Engineers, December 1998), www.ite.org/traffic/tcstate.htm#cgntc, a detailed review of the potential benefits and disbenefits of traffic calming measures was undertaken to provide some guidance in terms of device application to specific types of roadways and their impacts.  The following lists eight major considerations in selecting applicable traffic calming devices.

Potential General Benefits/Disbenefits of Traffic Calming Measures

Speed Reduction
Potential reduction in vehicle speeds along the traffic calmed street.
Volume Reduction
Potential reduction in volume of through traffic on a street.
Conflict Reduction
Potential reduction in road user conflicts.
Local Access
Extent to which a measure restricts local traffic.
Emergency Response
Potential delay as a result of slowing down to traverse a traffic calming measure and restriction of access.
Enforcement
The need for police enforcement for a measure to be effective.
Other Travel Modes
Access restrictions, safety implications or other disbenefits to pedestrians, bicycles, transit and service and delivery vehicles.
Maintenance
Increase maintenance time for snow clearing, street sweeping, garbage collection, maintenance of landscaping, etc.

Note: This information provides general benefits/disbenefits resulting from traffic calming installations.  The sections below summarize benefits/disbenefits of specific traffic calming devices.

Traffic Calming Devices

The Canadian Guide categorizes traffic calming devices into four broad categories.  Provided below is an overall comparison of the devices in each category, their intended function/benefits and potential disbenefits. Detailed information on the benefits and disbenefits can be found in the Canadian Guide.

Horizontal Deflection
Horizontal deflection devices include chicanes, curb extensions, corner radius reductions, on-street parking, raised median islands and traffic circles.

Artificial turns in a road created by a traffic calming device known as a chicane.
Chicane
 

Curb extensions on a road create additional space for pedestriansor ancillary uses.
Curb Extensions
 

A traffic circle in the middle of two opposing lanes.
Traffic Circle

Advantages:

  • Effective in reducing average and/or higher operating speed.
  • Devices such as curb extensions reduce road user conflict potential.
  • Devices typically do not impact emergency vehicle response times on lower order road.

Disadvantages:

  • Maintenance activities such as street cleaning and snow removal are complicated in the vicinity of device.
  • A number of the devices may impact transit and cyclist operations due to constrained travel portions of the roadway.
  • Typically do not impact through traffic volumes.

Vertical Deflection:
Vertical deflections include raised crosswalks, raised intersections, speed humps (as opposed to speed bumps which are typically found on private roads, laneways and in parking lots), and textured sidewalks.

Speed hump on an urban street.
Speed Hump

Raised crosswalk on an urban street.
Raised Crosswalk
 

Textured crosswalk on a busy downtown street.
Textured Crosswalk

Diverter on a quiet urban street to prevent drivers from cutting through to another road.
Diverter
 

Advantages:

  • Effective in reducing operating speeds.
  • Do not impact local access.


Disadvantages:

  • Devices have the potential to impact emergency vehicle response times, as they are required to slow down for the devices to ensure they do not damage their vehicles or upset their cargo or passenger.
  • Devices may increase maintenance requirements.
  • Typically do not impact through traffic volumes significantly.

Obstruction:

Included in this category are partial and full roadway closures, intersection diverters, raised medians and right-in-right-out channelized islands.  The main purpose of these devices is to reduce infiltrating traffic on neighbourhood streets.

Raised median on a quiet urban street.
Raised Median
 

Partial closure of an opposing lane on a busy urban street.
Partial Closure
 

Full closure at the end of a through road.
Full Closure

Advantages:

  • Reduces road user conflicts and volumes.

  • Requires little or no enforcement.

Disadvantages:

  • Penalizes local traffic access.

  • Reduces access to transit, emergency services, delivery service, etc.

  • Complicates road maintenance efforts in the vicinity of devices.

  • Potential to divert both local and through traffic to parallel or alternative routes.

Signing

These devices are sometimes used as traffic calming devices and include both regulatory and warning signs, including stop and yield controls, maximum speed, turn prohibitions, 'traffic calmed neighbourhood” signs.

Advantages:

  • Has the potential to reduce vehicle speeds and volumes.

  • Reduces road user conflicts.

  • Relatively inexpensive.

Disadvantages:

  • Frequent enforcement is required to be effective.

  • "Traffic calmed neighbourhood" and 'No through traffic” signs are not regulatory signs that can be enforced.

  • May reduce local access in the case of one-way streets and turn restrictions.